translated by the Saker community translators
The world elite is not ready to compromise with Moscow
The training of Australian submariners on the British nuclear submarine Anson is being carried out as part of the effort to put together a new Anglo-Saxon coalition on a world-wide scale. Photo from www.gov.uk
The most important political outcome of the outgoing year should become a radical change in Russia’s relations with the West. Not at the level of propaganda for the “plebeian multitudes”, but at the political, economic and, most importantly, mental level.
BEFORE AND NOW
At present, Russia’s complete and final break with the “collective West” (which means the countries of NATO, the EU, Switzerland, Australia, New Zealand, Japan and, with some reservations, the Republic of Korea, Taiwan and Singapore) is becoming not only an objective reality, but also an objective necessity. Over the past half century, the Western model of development has undergone a very serious degradation, and this degradation continues to deepen.
Half a century ago, the West, with its classical democracy, was qualitatively superior to the then Soviet Union in all respects – both in terms of the living standards and quality of life, and in terms of democratic freedoms (competitive elections, real pluralism of opinions, equality of all before the law). If a Soviet person had the opportunity to emigrate, only two things could stop them – patriotism (in relation to the country and its culture, and not to the system) or sincere adherence to communist ideology (although there has been no smell of communism in the USSR for a long time).
Today the situation has changed radically. The West still has some purely quantitative advantage over today’s Russia in the living standards and quality of life, but even that can be claimed only with very large reservations. As far as the level of democratic freedoms is concerned, the West and we have now became practically equal, and in some ways, perhaps, we even surpassed the West.
Therefore, today there are only two rational reasons for emigration – the guaranteed availability of a well-paid job in the West, or a fanatical adherence to the left-liberal ideology with its tolerance, the cult of “identities” and such things as the “cancellation culture” that have nothing to do with the real democracy.
WHO ARE ALL THESE PEOPLE
So, the Western model (even if taken independently of the current state of relations with the West) can no longer serve as a model or guide for Russia, thus reconciliation with the West becomes meaningless. At the same time, the reconciliation also became impossible due to the intellectual degradation of the Western political elites (which we will discuss later), due to their feminization and a significant presence of the representatives of sexual minorities. Who are, in fact, hired according to the quotas – as it was practiced in the USSR for workers and peasants.
Feminists and the representatives of sexual minorities make negative contribution to the politics of those states where they are allowed into the power structures. Moreover, all such people view Russia not so much as a geopolitical, but as an ideological adversary, reconciliation with whom is fundamentally impossible.
In addition, the West has absolutely inadequately assessed its “victory” in the Cold War, assuming Russia was a country which lost and which has to to acknowledge its defeat and live with that knowledge forever, giving up protection of its national interests ( “Russia and the West remain antagonists” , “NVO”, 12/15/17).
For all these reasons, modern Western elites will not make any compromises with Russia and will make no concessions. Because Russia’s concessions and accommodations to the West are unequivocally regarded by the West not just as a Russia’s weakness, but as the reason to apply even more pressure to achieve its unconditional surrender followed by its dismemberment into several states.
Nor will Russia be able to incorporate itself into the collective West on its own terms by force, which, it seems, our elites continue to aspire to to this day. For the West, any Russian success becomes just an excuse to try to isolate Russia as much as possible, to weaken and undermine it from within.
WESTERN WORLD DECLINE
There is no reason to hope that the Western elites will be replaced by some more adequate ones. The process of changing elites by itself takes decades. We don’t have that much time at our disposal.
But the main thing is that right now there is an ongoing progressive degradation of the Western elites taking place. If any of the Western politicians nowadays demonstrates even a minimal degree of adequacy, those, almost exclusively, are retired politicians of the old generation. Accordingly, even if the governments of the individual European countries change due to the socio-economic problems, nothing is going to change for Russia this winter.
For example, the right-wing coalition who denies the current Western left-liberal “tolerant-politically correct” political mainstream, won the recent parliamentary elections in Italy. At the same time, however, the winners immediately stated that there would be no changes in the support of Ukraine.
In Germany, Chancellor Scholz (he is 64 years old) is losing popularity very quickly. But the most popular political figure in the country, who could theoretically replace Scholz at his post, is the current foreign minister, 41-year-old Annalena Burbock, whose Russophobia is almost clinical.
It is unlikely that the activities of 47-year-old Liz Truss as a Prime Minister of Great Britain need additional commentary.
Here again we can turn to the Soviet example. It must be acknowledged that the level of education in the USSR was very high, which made a massive contribution to the collapse of the system and the country – it was thanks to good education and the ability to think critically that people realized the absurdity of the communist ideology and the falsity of propaganda.
The current West is much more consistent in this regard. The most powerful brainwashing through propaganda is combined not only with the gagging of any opponents, but also with an obvious drop in the quality of education. Therefore, there will be simply no one to understand the absurdity of the left-liberal ideology and the falsity of the propaganda. Accordingly, the quality of the elites will only worsen.
TURN FROM THE WEST
In connection with all these circumstances, the Russian elite should be purged to the maximum extent of the supporters of normalizing relations with the West, and of playing by the rules of the West. This is not about those who work directly for the West (this is a criminal offense). We are talking about those who are trying in one way or another to influence the domestic and foreign policy of Russia in this direction, without being formally a direct agent of the West.
It is especially necessary to rid the power structures of the people who have personal interests in the West (bank accounts, real estate, families living there, children studying there). Today, these people represent the main threat to the national security of the Russian Federation.
The same applies to the representatives of big business, who maintain close ties with the West and with Ukraine. It is extremely significant that, even after falling under Western sanctions, none of the Russian oligarchs provided any assistance to the Russian and allied army forces in Ukraine. Moreover, some of them, on the contrary, are ready to help Ukraine in order to earn the lifting of the sanctions.
Accordingly, for Russia there is no alternative to a complete break with the West. This means that it is necessary to stop any attempts to communicate with the West in any format (except for maintaining diplomatic relations).
It is necessary for ourselves at the mental level to break the long-established paradigm of identifying the collective West with the “world community” and the “civilized world”. The world community is all countries of the world without exception. The civilized world is also all countries, except, perhaps, some states of Tropical Africa. The opinion of a notional “Egypt” cannot be less valuable than the opinion of a notional “Belgium”.
Moscow needs to stop its attempts to prove to the world that it is not in the “international isolation”, as this only leads to senseless concessions to the West, which in turn create serious problems for us and do not provide us with the slightest benefit. A classic example of such a “breaking the isolation” was Russia’s participation in the Normandy format and the subsequent signing of the Minsk agreements in 2014. The purpose of these actions was precisely the “breaking the isolation” and a forceful insertion of ourselves into the formats with participation of two large Western countries – which was a gross mistake and brought us nothing but harm.
Instead, it had been necessary to finish off the current Kyiv regime and change the structure of Ukraine (at least by tearing away from it the eastern and southern regions from Kharkov to Odessa), which at that time would have been an order of magnitude easier task than now. In fact, all of our current losses in Ukraine are the result of signing of the Minsk agreements.
TURN TO THE EAST
The West should be assessed adequately and all the political and economic processes going on there should be watched. Now the US and UK are almost openly destroying the economy of the European Union, eliminating it as an economic competitor and facilitating transfer of the European industry and the most skilled workforce to the US.
By forcing European countries to transfer their already limited military equipment to Ukraine, the United States are trying to make the military potential of the European countries totally insignificant. They lose the ability to defend themselves not only individually, but even collectively. The destruction of economic and military potentials tightly binds Europe to the United States in the military-political sphere, making any relations with Europe completely meaningless for Russia (except, again, purely diplomatic ones).
This US policy further confirms the fact that NATO is of a value to Washington only politically, but not militarily. Ever since the end of World War II, the most important allied format for the Americans has been a coalition of five Anglo-Saxon countries.
However, New Zealand is geographically too isolated, its economic, demographic and military potentials are extremely insignificant, besides, it has long pursued a non-nuclear policy. Because of this, her value in the Anglo-Saxon coalition is limited. But Canada, Great Britain and Australia are truly the closest allies of the United States (this is manifested in all American military campaigns, starting from the same World War II), and their geographical position gives the coalition a global scale. Naturally, the format of this coalition is much broader than the intelligence cooperation known as the Five Eyes.
The UK, especially after leaving the EU, plays the role of the main “subcontractor” of the US in Europe. In particular, last year it was London that became the main “watchdog” on Ukraine instead of Washington itself ( “Washington promotes its little brother” , “NVO”, 07/16/21). At the same time, Great Britain became part of the Pacific Anglo-Saxon AUKUS format.
The fact of creation of AUKUS once again confirms that the United States is paying more and more attention to the Asia-Pacific region (APR). Since it has been clear for several decades that it is this region, and by no means the Euro-Atlantic one, that is now the “locomotive” of the world development ( “Imaginary Threats and Cynical Alliances” , “NVO”, 10/15/21).
In this regard, it is absolutely puzzling that Russia, which has direct geographical access to Asia-Pacific region, had, so far, paid minimal attention to it. During the post-Soviet period, Moscow has managed to make many “turns to the East”, but only in words. If we do not actually start doing this today, then it would be simply impossible not to recall the classic question of Pavel Milyukov: “What is this – stupidity or treason?
the West, with its classical democracy, was qualitatively superior to the then Soviet Union in all respects – both in terms of the living standards and quality of life, and in terms of democratic freedoms
But why is it constantly forgotten that the East was and remains the nursery of world’s scientists, artists and athletes. Wasn’t it a Soviet man who could go to Balshoi for 1 ruble, buy Turgeniev for 5 kopeicks. After all, the Soviet man was the one who had time and opportunity to read and travel, engage in amateurism and study. Working, sleeping and cleaning the pool – that’s not all the standard: l?!
Don’t we see that traditional and religious values have been preserved precisely in communist countries – and that is part of the quality of life too.
Saying that the “West” was “qualitatively superior” in the USSR in ALL respects is, I think, an exaggeration. You clearly don’t mean that. . As you actually point out so astutely in the second paragraph. Western QOL is a projection of Western propaganda — like Zelensky – fake.
https://julianmacfarlane.substack.com/p/zelensky-hero-or-villain?r=1flmbk .#julianmacfarlane #newsforensics #zelensky #dahmer #bundy #hitler #hollywood #Netflix #ukraine #propaganda #mediamadness
The West is cesspit and we deserve everything we are about to get. Democracy in the West is a fraud, just watch this 3 1/2 hour documentary:
JFK to 9/11 Everything is a Rich Man’s Trick
I think there’s a bit of comparing apples to borscht going on here. Russia has pursued a course of peace over the past 8 years, for several reasons. First and foremost, because peace is always preferable to war (unless you are the USMIC.) Saying they ‘should have taken Karkov to Odessa’ back then, which would have been ‘easier,’ ignores the fact that Russia was not in any sort of position to do such a thing at that time. Last April I had a conversation with a friend of mine, who was repeating the refrain of, “Russia is running out of bullets.” I told him that Russia has been preparing for war with NATO for 8 years. Actually, they’ve been preparing for WW3. This year they are ready.
The writer has many goof ideas. I suspect in other countries the same conversation is being made. The West ith :woke: ideology and rigged elections and being anri logic and reason is rapidly collapsing on all fronts.
“The West still has some purely quantitative advantage over today’s Russia in the living standards and quality of life”
It is all fake and will tumble down. The west has engaged in decades of money printing, which leads to in effect falsifying GDP and the appearance of “growth”. Just ask Greece what happens when the money printing stops. The money printing in the US is taking the form of a parabolic trajectory.
Western GDP is not false, it just measures irrelevance. Inflated weapons system add to GDP, as do financial fees and interest payments. Overpriced and poorly executed healthcare contributes as do rents and mortgage payments. And so on, which gives a false view of an economy. Thus, Obama said the Russia was a gas station with a flag, and she had a GDP the size of Italy’s—surprise, surprise when such a weak nation kicks ass!
“The most powerful brainwashing through propaganda is combined not only with the gagging of any opponents, but also with an obvious drop in the quality of education. Therefore, there will be simply no one to understand the absurdity of the left-liberal ideology and the falsity of the propaganda.”
The propaganda turns everything that used to be black and white into grey areas. When everything become grey, people cannot make decisions. You cannot follow a flow chart where each progressive step becomes yet another grey area.
The constant greying of things you used to know produces a population void of self-confidence and full of low self-esteem. Since they can no longer make decisions, decisions will have to be made for them.
Turning everything upside down is a purposeful act. Ideology is just offered as an excuse.
The constant propaganda at the expense of tangible objective facts by the USA / UK in this Ukraine conflict means to me they don’t want to engage decisively on the field of battle. why? They cant.
Poles are coming back in body bags at higher and higher rates. What other mercenaries are providing cannon fodder in serious numbers?
Taiwan recent election at the – local – regional – state legislative – level was decisively pro China – the President of Taiwan is alone with the uSA. With a thinking electorate – that is not corruptly fixed like the uSA but focused on their own interests – the Washington / Schaub cant maintain control.
Game is changing !
It is obvious that Russia must abandon any current Western “project”. In my opinion, nevertheless, it would be a mistake to severe all links with European societies. The EU project is trembling and a significant portion of the population, especially in the most “conservative” countries”, is fed up with all these woke nonsense and the ever-increasing cost of life. Therefore, popular reactions in the near future are likely. Russia should be able to give a helping hand.
Thanks for drawing a fine line. I believe Putin, Lavrov, etc. are smart enough to differentiate as well. Lavrov even identifies the USA as the real decision maker and the EU nations as pawns, willing or otherwise. I’m even told that an impoverished Europe is not in Russian interests, ergo (if I’m getting this right) Europe must be liberated from the Anglo jackboot.
For Russia to permanently cut ties with Europe and shift everything to Asia (a nightmare I once had two years ago) would mistakenly assume that the European nations can make their own decisions without the USA’s consent.
The world community is all countries of the world without exception. The civilized world is also all countries, except, perhaps, some states of Tropical Africa. The opinion of a notional “Egypt” cannot be less valuable than the opinion of a notional “Belgium”.
Dear Alexander Khramchikhin
I would rather stick to the no exception rule in the literal sense of the term, without “perhaps”
Would you meant “The opinion of a notional “Equatorial Guinea” cannot be less valuable than the opinion of a notional “Belgium”?
All propaganda is obfuscation, it results in confusion.
Confusion of the audience but of society as a whole.
After a while (generations) the whole mindset of society is so corrupt, that even the propagandist obfuscators lose their ability to think right. They not only believe in the previous lies but embed them into their own thinking processes. To the point there is nothing left but superstition.
It is fascinating to witness the current fading of western culture…
”In fact, all of our current losses in Ukraine are the result of signing of the Minsk agreements”… Wrong Russia was far from ready then so stop with the hind sight BS
«In this regard, it is absolutely puzzling that Russia, which has direct geographical access to Asia-Pacific region, had, so far, paid minimal attention to it.»
Resources are not unlimited, and there had to be at least some immediate dividends. The cost would have been prohibitive at those times. On the other side the purposes need time for maturing. Only today, that others are ready to invest in projects of shared interest, it is viable.
There would have been an augmented Atlantic pressure — but this topic is too complex to elaborate it here.
The author seems a trifle confused. He says such things as “the absurdity of the communist ideology “, but he wants Russia to turn to the East. But the largest economy in the East, China, is a communist country, and is very successful precisely because of that fact. Another large eastern power, Vietnam, also has a communist government. Communist government in China has enabled it to reign in the power of bankers and financial interests to take control of the economy to further their own interests. It has also allowed China to pull its people out of poverty, country wide. So communism does not seem to be ‘absurd’ after all. Perhaps the author would like to clarify this paradox?
There are two quotes as answer to yours.
One is William Shakespeare’s «What’s in a name? That which we call …».
The other is Deng Xiaoping’s «It doesn’t matter whether a cat is black or white, as long as it catches mice.»
p.s. Hint — “Communist ideology” is not a synonym for a “Communist dress’.
Ciccio_Bello you are oversimplifying with big name quotes put out of context. Try reading Domenico Losurdo ‘Fuga dalla storia?’, you will be able to see beyond dresses. Greetings
Your ‘reply’ neither answers or explains anything. China and Vietnam are much more than ‘communist’ in name only. You will have to do better than that.
Not particularly on topic. Regarding China vs Vietnam or any other country’s form of ‘communism.’ Probably better discussed over in the Movable Feast forums Please move it over there. Thanks. Mod
Sorry to double post – not was up on my screen as unpasted. Sorry about off-topic too :-)
Your ‘reply’ neither answers or explains anything. China and Vietnam are much more than ‘communist’ in name only. You will have to do better than that.
When Artyomovsk (Bakhmut) falls so does the collective hearts, minds and balls of the Western Elites, their Agents, Provocateurs & Killers.
We already hearing Macron distancing the EU’s participation. The f*cking Hellenistic Gaul of the Euro-shrimp bankers’ rent-boy.
That the French elected this POS again, he who months/years earlier gave orders to shoot, maim or kill demonstrators, beggar’s belief.
If he/they are not stopped now, we the sheeples will face firing squads.
Anglos are already preparing society and lamenting about the fall of Artyomovsk like London is about to burn down.
Russians should keep Bakhmut front “alive”, so that vultures keep sending scum to the meat grinder,
until expendables are terminated to the last one.
The hate is genuine and primordial. Stems from the inability to remove Russians from Earth.
The moment one exchanges a word with the hegemon, consider it one step closer to one’s demise.
The number one enemy of Russia is inferiority complex, along with justification of its own existence.
To whom? To the most notorious murderers and thieves planet has ever seen.
To the anglosaxon sect, a Satan’s private army on Earth.
Russia is not alone, just that the bear is too lazy to undertake and summon half the globe to her side, at the minimum. Install regimes and cut off world resources to the vultures.
The 20th century body count did not awake Russians. Why? What more reason do they want?
The hegemon is on the rampage, because it is unchallenged.